Greetings {first_name},

I hope this email finds you doing well. I am sending this to you to ask that you would allow us the opportunity to try to earn your business once again. We have gained access to new insurance companies since we originally quoted your insurance.  This means we have more options and can generally find you a better deal for you than what you currently have.  If you will allow us the opportunity to quote again, you simply just need to reply to this email stating so.   We already have all of your information from your previous quotes, so unless something has changed it will be a very simple process for you.  If there have been any changes it will still be simple, just put that info in your reply. Thank you again for giving us consideration once before!

The savings we have been providing all of our new customers have been insane.  On average we have been able to save over 70% of the clients we are quoting over $1,000 from what their prior insurance company was charging them.  Please give us a shot and see if you fall into that 70th percentile!